 |
Refugee Zundel
If life wasn't full of enough irony as it is, Ernst Zundel has
presented us all with a new one.
Ernst Zundel - the portly, Holocaust-denying hate propagandist
who fouled Canada's air for more than 40 years, before fleeing to
the United States in 2001 - is back in Canada, sitting in a detention
cell in southern Ontario. And he is claiming refugee status.
That's right: refugee status. Zundel fears being extradited to
his native Germany, where an arrest warrant awaits him, for his
willingness to defame Jewish dead, among other things. And therein
lays the irony: a hateful little man who loudly mocked and derided
Canada's refugee claimant system for decades, now seeking to avail
himself of the very protections it affords. If the consequences
were not so serious, the case would very nearly be comical.
And Ernst Zundel is, if nothing else, a serious problem. He immigrated
to Canada in 1958, at the age of 19, to escape military service
in West Germany. He earned a living, at first, as a commercial artist
and photo retoucher. And then, in 1978, the media revealed that,
under his middle names - Christoph Friedrich - Zundel had established
himself as Canada's leading Holocaust-denying propagandist.
Out of his fortified home in Toronto, he wrote and published screeds
with titles like The Hitler We Loved and Why. He published anti-Semitic
tracts authored by others, such as The Hoax of the Twentieth Century
and The Six Million Swindle. Most of all, he propagated hate. A
representative sampling of his views is found in the January 1977
of something called White Power Report: "The Jews give us,
their White hosts, wars, depressions, inflation, unemployment, energy
shortages, higher and higher taxes and air piracy," wrote Zundel.
"Like sheep, they expect us to go down the road with them -
all the way to the kosher slaughterhouse."
I have interviewed Zundel more than once, and have even debated
him. In one such encounter, he was forthright about who he was.
"Are you a National Socialist?" I asked him. He replied
that he was. "Nazi is the short form for National Socialist,
Mr. Zundel. Is that what you are? A Nazi?" The answer: "Yes."
He was not ashamed of it.
Successive Canadian governments were equally clear about their
desire to rid themselves of the Nazi named Ernst Zundel. But he
had legally obtained landed immigrant status, and permanent residency,
long before his neo-Nazi proselytizing became widely known. Through
the sales of countless anti-Semitic and white supremacist publications
around the globe, he was able to retain lawyers to confound many
of the subsequent legal attempts to rein him in.
In 1994, that changed. In that year, Zundel made a mistake: he
applied for Canadian citizenship. By doing so, he unwittingly set
in motion a process that enabled officials - including the Canadian
Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) - to start determining whether
he could be denied citizenship on the grounds that he was a threat
to national security. To many, there was no doubt he was - he had
funded violent neo-Nazi groups in Europe, and he had used his web
Zundelsite to propagate hatred around the globe.
Zundel fought hard, flooding the courts with motions and appeals,
but he saw the writing on the wall. In December 2000, the Supreme
Court of Canada refused to hear any more of his increasingly-arcane
legal arguments in the case. A few weeks later, Zundel fled to the
United States - where, in a letter issued by one of his lawyers,
he renounced his permanent residency status. There, he devoted himself
to his Zundelsite, defying a Canadian Human Rights Tribunal order
to remove hateful material.
Those hoping that we had seen the last of Ernst Zundel were to
be disappointed. Earlier this month, U.S. Immigration and Naturalization
Service agents arrested him at his home outside Knoxville, Tennessee.
Zundel had overstayed his visitor's visa, and the Americans - understandably
- wanted him to leave. Minutes after being handed over to Canadian
immigration authorities near Fort Erie, Ontario, Zundel claimed
refugee status.
There can be no doubt that Zundel has outwitted the system before.
But this time, I believe he will fail. Germany is a strong ally
of Canada, and democratic nation with some of the toughest anti-hate
laws in the world. It is offensive to accept, even for a moment,
that Germany is capable of the sorts of human rights abuses from
which legitimate refugees flee.
So as he sits in his jail cell in Southern Ontario, Ernst Zundel
can now contemplate a pair of ironies: the man whose Holocaust-denying
web site refers to the refugee system as "a racket," now
seeking to save his hide by taking advantage of it. The man who
professes to love Germany so much, desperate to avoid being sent
back there.
Let's finally do to this hateful little Holocaust denier what
should have been done long, long ago: when it comes time to debate
what he now seeks, let's deny him.
All contents copyright 2006 warrenkinsella.com.
No reproduction whatsoever, in any form, without permission.
|
 |