 |
The New Anti-Semitism
It was just an e-mail: not very long, written hurriedly, and copied
to a dozen friends. But, given that it had been sent this past week
from a young Canadian traveling in Israel given that it was
sent just hours after two dozen Jews were murdered in Tel Aviv
the e-mail had greater significance than most.
Not to worry I am OK, wrote the young woman,
a political assistant to a member of Ontarios legislature.
It is hard here, I tell you. As I write this, I really have
tears in my eyes. Can you imagine, living life never knowing what
might happen, what crazy person might decide to blow himself up
in
a blast that will kill maybe you and many others? Brothers, friends,
people you have never had the chance to meet yet? Can you imagine?
It could have been me.
The e-mail was chilling, but not just for the words that made it
up. It was chilling because it vividly made real something that,
for most of us, is a far-away abstraction a rote recitation
of body counts in the morning papers, a glimpse of ambulances flashing
by on the nightly news. It was real: Jews being slaughtered, daily,
for the crime of being Jews. Without pause, without mercy. Anti-Semitism,
the Beast, is awake once more.
To Jews and those others who still pay attention, of course, the
Beast was never fully asleep. In every country, in every region,
anti-Semitism usually manifests itself in the usual ways: swastikas
scrawled on the doors of synagogues, Orthodox children being beaten
up, neo-Nazis denying the Holocaust on the Internet. But in the
past year or so, there has been a perceptible change. The virus
has become much more virulent; it has mutated.
The traditional allies of anti-Semitism are economic dislocation,
conflicts in the Middle East, ignorance. These pretexts for hate
have lately been joined by some new ones: the second Intifada, right
wing political populism, anti-globalization conspiracy theorists,
September 11-related tensions, and even the intellectualization
of Jew hatred on university campuses. You have been hearing more
about anti-Semitism, these days, for the simple reason that there
is more of it.
The Beast walks Canada, too, and not simply because an editorialist
at the Jerusalem Post said so. In a widely-reported opinion piece
published at Christmas, the Post declared: With the rising
tide of anti-Jewish hostility in Europe getting so much attention
in recent months, it is somewhat surprising that an equally worrisome
trend across the Atlantic has gone largely unnoticed mounting
anti-Semitism in Canada. The editorial probably exaggerated
a little. But not by much.
Proof of this is found in an interim audit of anti-Semitic incidents
recently released by Bnai Briths League for Human Rights
interim because the League was alarmed enough
to report, mid-way through 2002, about burgeoning anti-Semitism
in Canada. February: a Montreal theatre running a film with Jewish
content firebombed. April: a Saskatoon synagogue firebombed.
May: a pipe bomb tossed at Quebec Citys only remaining synagogue.
June: threats of violence mailed to a score of Jewish organizations
and, in some cases, envelopes filled with an ominous white
powder. In all, 197 anti-Semitic incidents reported between January
and June 2002, nearly double the figure from the same period in
2001.
Some of the anti-Semitism seeping out the sewers was, to be sure,
the sort of intolerance typically practiced by Canadas far
right and therefore nothing dramatically new. And the far
right hate was not restricted to Jews alone, either: in the wake
of September 11, Canadian Muslims have also been placed near the
top of the haters victim list.
But in Canada, and other Western democracies, anti-Semitism has
received an unexpected boost from an unlikely source: the ideological
Left. In 1967, no less than Martin Luther King wrote that anti-Zionism
is inherently anti-Semitic, and ever will be so. That has
not stopped academics and supposed thinkers from dressing up Jew
hatred in anti-Zionist rhetoric. Even Canadian stalwarts
like lawyer Clayton Ruby and union leader Jeff Rose have written
that anti-Semitism has grown to be a powerful force
in parts of Canadas Left.
As the Jerusalem Post noted, anti-Zionist agitation
has captured headlines on a number of Canadian campuses, where progressive
thought is supposed to trump reactionary causes. It was most vividly
on display at Concordia University in September 2002, when an attempted
speech by former Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu degenerated
into a riot.
Anti-Semitic themes have permeated other parts of the Left, as
well. Opponents of globalization have permitted odious anti-Semitic
screeds such as the infamous Protocols of the Learned Elders
of Zion, which attempts to supply proof of an international
Jewish conspiracy to be posted on well-used anti-trade news
services such as www.indymedia.org. The problem is not unique to
Canada. Harvard University president Lawrence H. Summers has warned
that some academics are taking actions that are anti-Semitic
in their effect if not their intent.
Meanwhile, traditional allies of the Jewish community from within
the notional Left including African-Americans, unions, aboriginals
and environmentalists have embraced (or shown profound indifference
to) the new global anti-Semitism. From the Nation of Islam, to the
American Indian Movement (to Canadian aboriginal leaders like David
Ahenakew), to the Green Party all have had well-documented
dalliances with anti-Semitism that disingenuously refers to itself
as anti-Zionism.
It hardly bears mentioning that not every criticism of Israel is
anti-Semitic. And nor is anti-Semitism as prevalent now as it was
in medieval England, or 16th century Spain, or 20th century Germany.
But, as noted by the young friend traveling in Israel (and now safely
home): Jews and therefore all of us live in dangerous
times.
Only together are we strong, she wrote in her e-mail,
providing the best ending of all. Only together can we prevail
against terrorism.
As e-mails go, it was one to remember.
All contents copyright 2006 warrenkinsella.com.
No reproduction whatsoever, in any form, without permission.
|
 |