October 7: two years
[Short speech I gave at noon today at Belleville City Hall for an October 7 vigil.]
Standing here today is an act of defiance.
It’s a symbol of unity on a day of remembrance. It’s an expression of community.
But for me, an Irish Catholic Zionist, it is defiance.
After Manchester – after Washington DC, after Minneapolis, after Boulder Colorado, after too many lives lost – we all know there is a risk, no matter how remote, in gathering here together today.
But be together we must. We must.
We must show our commitment to civilization. To decency. To humanity. To each other.
We must show our opposition to the beast of antisemitism and hate, which is now everywhere to be seen. We must fight back.
We do that by always remembering the hostages, and calling for their release. We do that by remembering those we have lost. We do that by pushing back against the black tide of antisemitism and hatred.
We do that, too, by simply being here together, right now, and saying: you will not cancel us. You will not silence us. You will not replace us.
October 7 was one of the darkest days of our lifetimes. Words alone cannot describe it.
October 7 places in obligation on the shoulders of all of us. It requires us to remember the men, women and children who had life taken from them by monsters in the shape of men – and it requires us to ensure that it never, ever happens again.
We do that in many ways. We do that by gathering here, now on this day, to say:
We will defy the haters. We will defeat them. The Jewish people have been here for thousands of years – and the Jewish people will be here for thousands of years to come.
As Dr. Martin Luther King, another proud Christian Zionist, said: “Darkness cannot drive out darkness. Only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate. Only love can do that.”
We have love, and humanity and civilization on our side. We have decency and and the truth on our side. And with those things, the forces of hate will never, ever defeat us.